ABS vs ASA: which one should you use?

They print in a similar way, but they are built for different jobs. Here is how to choose.

The short answer

ASA is usually the better choice for parts that will spend long periods outdoors or exposed to sunlight. Choose ABS for indoor parts, especially if you plan to smooth them with acetone or want the widest choice of colors and brands.

Side-by-side

ABSASA
Sunlight & weatherCan yellow and get brittle with long sun exposureDesigned for improved UV and weather resistance
Heat resistanceGood, well above PLAGood, similar to ABS
EnclosureStrongly recommendedStrongly recommended
WarpingProne to warpingProne to warping; many people find it slightly easier than ABS
FumesNoticeable smell; ventilateNoticeable smell; ventilate
Acetone smoothingYesYes, often with less dramatic results
FinishUsually glossy to satinOften a more matte finish
Availability & priceVery common, usually lower costLess common, usually costs a bit more

What they have in common

Both are styrene-based plastics. ABS uses butadiene rubber for toughness. ASA swaps that for an acrylate rubber, which is the main reason it handles sunlight better. Because they are so similar, the same printer setup works for both: a hot bed, an enclosure, little or no part cooling, and good ventilation.

Choose ASA if…

Choose ABS if…

What about PETG?

If you don't have an enclosure or the part doesn't need the higher heat resistance of ABS or ASA, PETG is often easier to print and typically produces less noticeable odor. It is a good middle ground between PLA and ABS/ASA for many functional parts.